Background Image

...

In Quantum Mechanics There Is A Causing B. The Equations Do Not Stand Outside That Usual Paradigm Of Physics. The Real Issue Is That The Kinds Of Things You Predict In Quantum Mechanics Are Different From The Kinds Of Things You Predict Using General Relativity. Quantum Mechanics, That Big, New, Spectacular Remarkable Idea Is That You Only Predict Probabilities, The Likelihood Of One Outcome Or Another. That's The New Idea.

-Brian Greene

...

Please Wait....
Translating....

In Quantum Mechanics There

Brian Greene

...

In Quantum Mechanics There Is A Causing B. The Equations Do Not Stand Outside That Usual Paradigm Of Physics. The Real Issue Is That The Kinds Of Things You Predict In Quantum Mechanics Are Different From The Kinds Of Things You Predict Using General Relativity. Quantum Mechanics, That Big, New, Spectacular Remarkable Idea Is That You Only Predict Probabilities, The Likelihood Of One Outcome Or Another. That's The New Idea.

Views: 5

Topic

More From Brian Greene

Science Is A Way Of Life. Science Is A Perspective. Science Is The Process That Takes Us From Confusion To Understanding In A Manner That's Precise, Predictive And Reliable - A Transformation, For Those Lucky Enough To Experience It, That Is Empowering And Emotional.

In Quantum Mechanics There Is A Causing B. The Equations Do Not Stand Outside That Usual Paradigm Of Physics. The Real Issue Is That The Kinds Of Things You Predict In Quantum Mechanics Are Different From The Kinds Of Things You Predict Using General Relativity. Quantum Mechanics, That Big, New, Spectacular Remarkable Idea Is That You Only Predict Probabilities, The Likelihood Of One Outcome Or Another. That's The New Idea.

Oftentimes, If You're Talking To A Seasoned Interviewer Who Asks You A Question, They May Do A Follow-up If They Didn't Quite Get It. It's Rare That They'll Do A Third Or Fourth Or Fifth Or Sixth Follow-up, Because There's An Implicit, Agreed-upon Decorum That They Move On. Kids Don't Necessarily Move On If They Don't Get It.

But If You Think About A Practical Implication Of Enriching Your Life And Giving You A Sense Of Being Part Of A Larger Cosmos And Possibly Being Able To Use This [gravitational Waves] As A Tool In The Future Maybe To Listen Not Just To Black Holes Colliding, But Maybe Listen To The Big Bang Itself, Those Kind Of Applications May Happen In The Not Too Distant Future.

Cosmology Is Among The Oldest Subjects To Captivate Our Species. And It’s No Wonder. We’re Storytellers, And What Could Be More Grand Than The Story Of Creation?

We Do Not Know Whether There Are Extra Dimensions Or Multiverse. Let's Go Forward With The Possible Ideas That Come Out Of The Mathematics. It's Hard For Us To Imagine A Universe That Would Have No Time At All.

String Theory Is The Most Developed Theory With The Capacity To Unite General Relativity And Quantum Mechanics In A Consistent Manner. I Do Believe The Universe Is Consistent, And Therefore I Do Believe That General Relativity And Quantum Mechanics Should Be Put Together In A Manner That Makes Sense.

Most Scientists Like To Operate In The Context Of Economy. If You Don't Need An Explanatory Principle, Don't Invoke It.

No Matter How Hard You Try To Teach Your Cat General Relativity, You're Going To Fail.

So Many Galaxies, So Many Planets Out There In The Universe Circling So Many Stars... It Just Feels Like There's A Very Good Chance That There Is Another Earth-like Planet Out There That Is Able To Support Some Kind Of Life Similar To What We're Familiar With.

String Theory Has The Potential To Show That All Of The Wondrous Happenings In The Universe - From The Frantic Dance Of Subatomic Quarks To The Stately Waltz Of Orbiting Binary Stars; From The Primordial Fireball Of The Big Bang To The Majestic Swirl Of Heavenly Galaxies - Are Reflections Of One, Grand Physical Principle, One Master Equation.

When General Relativity Was First Put Forward In 1915, The Math Was Very Unfamiliar To Most Physicists. Now We Teach General Relativity To Advanced High School Students.

Black Holes Provide Theoreticians With An Important Theoretical Laboratory To Test Ideas. Conditions Within A Black Hole Are So Extreme, That By Analyzing Aspects Of Black Holes We See Space And Time In An Exotic Environment, One That Has Shed Important, And Sometimes Perplexing, New Light On Their Fundamental Nature.

Science Is Very Good At Answering The 'how' Questions. 'how Did The Universe Evolve To The Form That We See?' But It Is Woefully Inadequate In Addressing The 'why' Questions. 'why Is There A Universe At All?' These Are The Meaning Questions, Which Many People Think Religion Is Particularly Good At Dealing With.

To Tell You The Truth, I've Never Met Anybody Who Can Envision More Than Three Dimensions. There Are Some Who Claim They Can, And Maybe They Can; It's Hard To Say.

Art Makes Us Human, Music Makes Us Human, And I Deeply Feel That Science Makes Us Human.

We're On This Planet For The Briefest Of Moments In Cosmic Terms, And I Want To Spend That Time Thinking About What I Consider The Deepest Questions.

In The Far, Far Future, Essentially All Matter Will Have Returned To Energy. But Because Of The Enormous Expansion Of Space, This Energy Will Be Spread So Thinly That It Will Hardly Ever Convert Back To Even The Lightest Particles Of Matter. Instead, A Faint Mist Of Light Will Fall For Eternity Through An Ever Colder And Quieter Cosmos.

If The Theory Turns Out To Be Right, That Will Be Tremendously Thick And Tasty Icing On The Cake.

We Are Living Through A Remarkably Privileged Era When Certain Deep Truths About The Cosmos Are Still Within Reach Of The Human Spirit Of Exploration.

All You Are Is A Bag Of Particles Acting Out The Laws Of Physics. That To Me Is Pretty Clear.

Time Allows Change To Take Place And The Very Evolution Of The Universe Is What Requires Some Conception Of Time. Mathematically Can We Write Down A Universe That Doesn't Have Time? Sure. Do We Think That Would Be Realised In The Larger Reality That Is Out There? None Of Us Take That Possibility Seriously.

I've Seen Children's Eyes Light Up When I Tell Them About Black Holes And The Big Bang.

Many Different Planets Are Many Different Distances From Their Host Star; We Find Ourselves At This Distance Because If We Were Closer Or Farther Away, The Temperature Would Be Hotter Or Colder, Eliminating Liquid Water, An Essential Ingredient For Our Survival.

Nature's Patterns Sometimes Reflect Two Intertwined Features: Fundamental Physical Laws And Environmental Influences. It's Nature's Version Of Nature Versus Nurture.

When I Give This Talk To A Physics Audience, I Remove The Quotes From My 'theorem'.

Physics Grapples With The Largest Questions The Universe Presents. Where Did The Totality Of Reality Come From? Did Time Have A Beginning?

My Emotional Investment Is In Finding Truth. If String Theory Is Wrong, I'd Like To Have Known That Yesterday. But If We Can Show It Today Or Tomorrow, Fantastic.

Physicists Are More Like Avant-garde Composers, Willing To Bend Traditional Rules... Mathematicians Are More Like Classical Composers.

Energy Is The Ultimate Convertable Currency.

The Boldness Of Asking Deep Questions May Require Unforeseen Flexibility If We Are To Accept The Answers.

Writing For The Stage Is Different From Writing For A Book. You Want To Write In A Way That An Actor Has Material To Work With, Writing In The First Person Not The Third Person, And Pulling Out The Dramatic Elements In A Bigger Way For A Stage Presentation.

That Is, You Can Have Nothingness, Absolute Nothingness For Maybe A Tiny Fraction Of A Second, If A Second Can Be Defined In That Arena, But Then It Falls Apart Into A Something And An Anti-something. And That Something Is Then What We Call The Universe. But Can We Really Understand That Or Put Rigorous Mathematics Or Testable Experiments Against That? Not Yet. So One Of The Big Holy Grail Of Physics Is To Understand Why There Is Something Rather Than Nothing.

The Main Challenge That Television Presents Is That I Have A Tendency To Say Things With A Great Deal Of Precision And Accuracy. Often A Description Of That Sort, Which Will Work In A Book Because People Can Read It Slowly - They Can Turn The Pages Back And So On - Doesn't Really Work On Tv Because It Interrupts The Flow Of The Moving Image.

There Are Many Of Us Thinking Of One Version Of Parallel Universe Theory Or Another. If It's All A Lot Of Nonsense, Then It's A Lot Of Wasted Effort Going Into This Far-out Idea. But If This Idea Is Correct, It Is A Fantastic Upheaval In Our Understanding.

A Watch Worn By A Particle Of Light Would Not Tick At All. Light Realizes The Dreams Of Ponce De Leon And The Cosmetics Industry: It Doesn't Age.

Sometimes Attaining The Deepest Familiarity With A Question Is Our Best Substitute For Actually Having The Answer.

Supersymmetry Is A Theory Which Stipulates That For Every Known Particle There Should Be A Partner Particle. For Instance, The Electron Should Be Paired With A Supersymmetric 'selectron,' Quarks Ought To Have 'squark' Partners, And So On.

For Me It's Been Very Exciting To Contribute To The Public's Understanding Of How Rich And Wondrous Science Is.

Free Will Is The Sensation Of Making A Choice. The Sensation Is Real, But The Choice Seems Illusory. Laws Of Physics Determine The Future.

Einstein's Theory Of Relativity Does A Fantastic Job For Explaining Big Things. Quantum Mechanics Is Fantastic For The Other End Of The Spectrum - For Small Things.

A Unified Theory Would Put Us At The Doorstep Of A Vast Universe Of Things That We Could Finally Explore With Precision.

...things Are The Way They Are In Our Universe Because If They Weren't, We Wouldn't Be Here To Notice.

Before The Discovery Of Quantum Mechanics, The Framework Of Physics Was This: If You Tell Me How Things Are Now, I Can Then Use The Laws Of Physics To Calculate, And Hence Predict, How Things Will Be Later.

I Love It When Real Science Finds A Home In A Fictional Setting, Where You Take Some Real Core Idea Of Science And Weave It Through A Fictional Narrative In Order To Bring It To Life, The Way Stories Can. That's My Favorite Thing.

I May Be A Jewish Scientist, But I Would Be Tickled Silly If One Day I Were Reincarnated As A Baptist Preacher.

For Most People, The Major Hurdle In Grasping Modern Insights Into The Nature Of The Universe Is That These Developments Are Usually Phrased Using Mathematics.

The Bottom Line Is That Time Travel Is Allowed By The Laws Of Physics.

When You Buy A Jacket, You Pick The Size To Ensure It Fits. Similarly, We Live In A Universe In Which The Amount Of Dark Energy Fits Our Biological Make-up. If The Amount Of Dark Energy Were Substantially Different From What We've Measured, The Environmental Conditions Would Be Inhospitable To Our Form Of Life.

I Wouldn't Say That The Fabric Of The Cosmos Is A Book On Cosmology. Cosmology Certainly Plays A Big Part, But The Major Theme Is Our Ever-evolving Understanding Of Space And Time, And What It All Means For Our Sense Of Reality.

Quantum Mechanics Is Different. Its Weirdness Is Evident Without Comparison. It Is Harder To Train Your Mind To Have Quantum Mechanical Tuition, Because Quantum Mechanics Shatters Our Own Personal, Individual Conception Of Reality

But, As Einstein Once Said, “for We Convinced Physicists, The Distinction Between Past, Present, And Future Is Only An Illusion, However Persistent.”5

There's No Way That Scientists Can Ever Rule Out Religion, Or Even Have Anything Significant To Say About The Abstract Idea Of A Divine Creator.

I'd Say Many Features Of String Theory Don't Mesh With What We Observe In Everyday Life.

Every Moment Is As Real As Every Other. Every 'now,' When You Say, 'this Is The Real Moment,' Is As Real As Every Other 'now' - And Therefore All The Moments Are Just Out There. Just As Every Location In Space Is Out There, I Think Every Moment In Time Is Out There, Too.

When You Drive Your Car, E = Mc2 Is At Work. As The Engine Burns Gasoline To Produce Energy In The Form Of Motion, It Does So By Converting Some Of The Gasoline's Mass Into Energy, In Accord With Einstein's Formula.

I Believe That Through Its Rational Evaluation Of Truth And Indifference To Personal Belief, Science Transcends Religious And Political Divisions And So Does Bind Us Into A Greater, More Resilient Whole.

...quantum Mechanics—the Physics Of Our World—requires That You Hold Such Pedestrian Complaints In Abeyance.

The Beauty Of String Theory Is The Metaphor Kind Of Really Comes Very Close To The Reality. The Strings Of String Theory Are Vibrating The Particles, Vibrating The Forces Of Nature Into Existence, Those Vibrations Are Sort Of Like Musical Notes. So String Theory, If It's Correct, Would Be Playing Out The Score Of The Universe.

Experimental Evidence Is The Final Arbiter Of Right And Wrong.

The Universe Is Incredibly Wondrous, Incredibly Beautiful, And It Fills Me With A Sense That There Is Some Underlying Explanation That We Have Yet To Fully Understand. If Someone Wants To Place The Word 'god' On Those Collections Of Words, It's Ok With Me.

Gravity Is Matter’s Sugar Daddy.

My Best Teachers Were Not The Ones Who Knew All The Answers, But Those Who Were Deeply Excited By Questions They Couldn't Answer.

Black Holes, We All Know, Are These Regions Where If An Object Falls In, It Can't Get Out, But The Puzzle That Many Struggled With Over The Decades Is, What Happens To The Information That An Object Contains When It Falls Into A Black Hole. Is It Simply Lost?

The Absolute Worst Thing That You Ever Can Do, In My Opinion, In Bringing Science To The General Public, Is Be Condescending Or Judgmental. It Is So Opposite To The Way Science Needs To Be Brought Forth.

I Can't Stand Clutter. I Can't Stand Piles Of Stuff. And Whenever I See It, I Basically Just Throw The Stuff Away.

I Have Long Thought That Anyone Who Does Not Regularly - Or Ever - Gaze Up And See The Wonder And Glory Of A Dark Night Sky Filled With Countless Stars Loses A Sense Of Their Fundamental Connectedness To The Universe.

One Of The Wonders Of Science Is That It Is Completely Universal. It Crosses National Boundaries With Total Ease.

In My Own Research When I'm Working With Equations, I Never Feel Like I Really Understand What I'm Doing If I'm Solely Relying On The Mathematics For My Understanding. I Need To Have A Visual Picture In My Mind. I'm Constantly Translating From The Math To Some Intuitive Mind's-eye Picture.

I Can Assure You That No String Theorist Would Be Interested In Working On String Theory If It Were Somehow Permanently Beyond Testability. That Would No Longer Be Doing Science.

So: If You Buy The Notion That Reality Consists Of The Things In Your Freeze-frame Mental Image Right Now, And If You Agree That Your Now Is No More Valid Than The Now Of Someone Located Far Away In Space Who Can Move Freely, Then Reality Encompasses All Of The Events In Spacetime.

We Can Certainly Go Further Than Cats, But Why Should It Be That Our Brains Are Somehow So Suited To The Universe That Our Brains Will Be Able To Understand The Deepest Workings?

According To Inflation, The More Than 100 Billion Galaxies, Sparkling Throughout Space Like Heavenly Diamonds, Are Nothing But Quantum Mechanics Writ Large Across The Sky. To Me, This Realization Is One Of The Greatest Wonders Of The Modern Scientific Age.

I Was Holding [my Four-year-old Daughter] And I Said, 'sophia, I Love You More Than Anything In The Universe.' And She Turned To Me And Said, 'daddy, Universe Or Multiverse?'

I Love You More

Understanding Requires Insight. Insight Must Be Anchored.

In Any Finite Region Of Space, Matter Can Only Arrange Itself In A Finite Number Of Configurations, Just As A Deck Of Cards Can Be Arranged In Only Finitely Many Different Orders. If You Shuffle The Deck Infinitely Many Times, The Card Orderings Must Necessarily Repeat.

The Revelation We've Come To Is That We Can Trust Our Memories Of A Past With Lower, Not Higher, Entropy Only If The Big Bang - The Process, Event, Or Happening That Brought The Universe Into Existence - Started Off The Universe In An Extraordinarily Special, Highly Ordered State Of Low Entropy.

Physicists Have Come To Realize That Mathematics, When Used With Sufficient Care, Is A Proven Pathway To Truth.

Sometimes Nature Guards Her Secrets With The Unbreakable Grip Of Physical Law. Sometimes The True Nature Of Reality Beckons From Just Beyond The Horizon.

Assessing Existence While Failing To Embrace The Insights Of Modern Physics Would Be Like Wrestling In The Dark With An Unknown Opponent.

General Relativity Is In The Old Newtonian Framework Where You Predict What Will Happen, Not The Probability Of What Will Happen. And Putting Together The Probabilities Of Quantum Mechanics With The Certainty Of General Relativity, That's Been The Big Challenge And That's Why We Have Been Excited About String Theory, As It's One Of The Only Approaches That Can Put It Together.

Evidence In Support Of General Relativity Came Quickly. Astronomers Had Long Known That Mercury’s Orbital Motion Around The Sun Deviated Slightly From What Newton’s Mathematics Predicted. In 1915, Einstein Used His New Equations To Recalculate Mercury’s Trajectory And Was Able To Explain The Discrepancy, A Realization He Later Described To His Colleague Adrian Fokker As So Thrilling That For Some Hours It Gave Him Heart Palpitations.

I Think It's Too Fast To Say That All Sci-fi Ultimately Winds Up Having Some Place In Science. On The Other Hand, Imaginative Minds Working Outside Of Science As Storytellers Certainly Have Come Upon Ideas That, With The Passing Decades, Have Either Materialized Of Come Close To Materializing.

I Like To Think That Einstein Would Look At String Theory’s Journey And Smile, Enjoying The Theory’s Remarkable Geometrical Features While Feeling Kinship With Fellow Travelers On The Long And Winding Road Toward Unification.

Einstein Comes Along And Says, Space And Time Can Warp And Curve, That's What Gravity Is. Now String Theory Comes Along And Says, Yes, Gravity, Quantum Mechanics, Electromagnetism - All Together In One Package, But Only If The Universe Has More Dimensions Than The Ones That We See.

There May Be Many Big Bangs That Happened At Various And Far-flung Locations, Each Creating Its Own Swelling, Spatial Expanse, Each Creating A Universe - Our Universe Being The Result Of Only One Of Those Big Bangs.

How Can A Speck Of A Universe Be Physically Identical To The Great Expanse We View In The Heavens Above?

Far From Being Accidental Details, The Properties Of Nature's Basic Building Blocks Are Deeply Entwined With The Fabric Of Space And Time.

Most People Don’t Question The Practice Of Eating Meat. Many Of These People Care About Animals And The Environment, Some Deeply. But For Some Reason-force Of Habit, Cultural Norms, Resistance To Change-there Is A Fundamental Disconnect Whereby These Feelings Don’t Translate Into Changes Of Behavior.

The Real Question Is Whether All Your Pondering And Analyses Will Convince You That Life Is Worth Living. That's What It All Comes Down To.

The Idea That There Could Be Other Universes Out There Is Really One That Stretches The Mind In A Great Way.

Intelligence Is The Ability To Take In Information From The World And To Find Patterns In That Information That Allow You To Organize Your Perceptions And Understand The External World.

When We Benefit From Ct Scanners, M.r.i. Devices, Pacemakers And Arterial Stents, We Can Immediately Appreciate How Science Affects The Quality Of Our Lives.

I Think Math Is A Hugely Creative Field, Because There Are Some Very Well-defined Operations That You Have To Work Within. You Are, In A Sense, Straightjacketed By The Rules Of The Mathematics. But Within That Constrained Environment, It's Up To You What You Do With The Symbols.

The Melded Nature Of Space And Time Is Intimately Woven With Properties Of Light Speed. The Inviolable Nature Of The Speed Of Light Is Actually, In Einstein's Hands, Talking About The Inviolable Nature Of Cause And Effect.

You Should Never Be Surprised By Or Feel The Need To Explain Why Any Physical System Is In A High Entropy State.

I Believe We Owe Our Young An Education That Captures The Exhilarating Drama Of Science.

When Kids Look Up To Great Scientists The Way They Do To Great Musicians And Actors, Civilization Will Jump To The Next Level

The Number Of E-mails And Letters That I Get From Choreographers, From Sculptors, From Composers Who Are Being Inspired By Science Is Huge.

It's Hard To Teach Passionately About Something That You Don't Have A Passion For.

I Believe The Process Of Going From Confusion To Understanding Is A Precious, Even Emotional, Experience That Can Be The Foundation Of Self-confidence.

Self Confidence

I Like 'the Simpsons' Quite A Lot. I Love The Irreverent Character Of The Whole Show. It's Great.

Our Eyes Only See The Big Dimensions, But Beyond Those There Are Others That Escape Detection Because They Are So Small.

String Theory Envisions A Multiverse In Which Our Universe Is One Slice Of Bread In A Big Cosmic Loaf. The Other Slices Would Be Displaced From Ours In Some Extra Dimension Of Space.

The Central Idea Of String Theory Is Quite Straightforward. If You Examine Any Piece Of Matter Ever More Finely, At First You'll Find Molecules, Atoms, Sub-atomic Particles. Probe The Smaller Particles, You'll Find Something Else, A Tiny Vibrating Filament Of Energy, A Little Tiny Vibrating String.

Science Is The Process That Takes Us From Confusion To Understanding.

When You Know The Answer You Want, It Is Often All Too Easy To Figure Out A Way Of Getting It.

The Pinpoints Of Starlight We See With The Naked Eye Are Photons That Have Been Streaming Toward Us For A Few Years Or A Few Thousand.

I’ve Spent Something Like 17 Years Working On A Theory For Which There Is Essentially No Direct Experimental Support.

We Might Be The Holographic Image Of A Two-dimensional Structure.

There's A Picture Of My Dorm Room In The College Yearbook As The Most Messy, Most Disgusting Room On The Harvard Campus, Where I Was An Undergraduate.

Exploring The Unknown Requires Tolerating Uncertainty.

If String Theory Is Right, The Microscopic Fabric Of Our Universe Is A Richly Intertwined Multidimensional Labyrinth Within Which The Strings Of The Universe Endlessly Twist And Vibrate, Rhythmically Beating Out The Laws Of The Cosmos.

I Enjoy Reading Blogs, But Am Not Interested In Having My Spurious Thoughts Out There.

The Fact That I Don't Have Any Particular Need For Religion Doesn't Mean That I Have A Need To Cast Religion Aside The Way Some Of My Colleagues Do.

I've Had Various Experiences Where I've Been Called By Hollywood Studios To Look At A Script Or Comment On Various Scientific Ideas That They're Trying To Inject Into A Story.

All Mathematics Is Is A Language That Is Well Tuned, Finely Honed, To Describe Patterns; Be It Patterns In A Star, Which Has Five Points That Are Regularly Arranged, Be It Patterns In Numbers Like 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 That Follow Very Regular Progression.

Relativity Challenges Your Basic Intuitions That You've Built Up From Everyday Experience. It Says Your Experience Of Time Is Not What You Think It Is, That Time Is Malleable. Your Experience Of Space Is Not What You Think It Is; It Can Stretch And Shrink.

Science Is The Greatest Of All Adventure Stories, One That's Been Unfolding For Thousands Of Years As We Have Sought To Understand Ourselves And Our Surroundings.

I Would Say In One Sentence My Goal Is To At Least Be Part Of The Journey To Find The Unified Theory That Einstein Himself Was Really The First To Look For.

Falsifiability For A Theory Is Great, But A Theory Can Still Be Respectable Even If It Is Not Falsifiable, As Long As It Is Verifiable.

I Think The Relationship Between Memory And Time Is A Very Deep And Tricky One, To Tell You The Truth. I Don't Consider Memory Another Sense. I Do Consider Memory That Which Allows Us To Think That Time Flows.

In Essence, We String Theorists Have Been Trying To Work Out The Score Of The Universe, The Harmonies Of The Universe, The Mathematical Vibrations That The Strings Would Play. So Musical Metaphors Have Been With Us In Science Since The Beginning.

Over The Centuries, Monumental Upheavals In Science Have Emerged Time And Again From Following The Leads Set Out By Mathematics.

The Tantalizing Discomfort Of Perplexity Is What Inspires Otherwise Ordinary Men And Women To Extraordinary Feats Of Ingenuity And Creativity; Nothing Quite Focuses The Mind Like Dissonant Details Awaiting Harmonious Resolution.

Trending Author

Phyllis McGinley

Shana Alexander

Category