Background Image

...

Enclave Life Becomes Very Tense, Even When They Do Elect A Leader, The Factions Remain, With The Threat Of Splitting Off.

-Mary Douglas

...

Please Wait....
Translating....

Enclave Life Becomes Very

Mary Douglas

...

Enclave Life Becomes Very Tense, Even When They Do Elect A Leader, The Factions Remain, With The Threat Of Splitting Off.

Views: 12

Topic

More From Mary Douglas

I Have Increasingly, Over The Years, Felt That Religion Today Does Our Civilization More Harm Than Good.

Since 1970, Relationships Can Be More Volatile, Jobs More Ephemeral, Geographical Mobility More Intensified, Stability Of Marriage Weaker.

Mormons... Are So Strong, They Can Handle Wealth, They Are Confident. I Think It Is Because They Are Not Bogged Down By Rules For Equality, But Have A Firmly Defined System Of Relative Status And Responsible Command.

Behind A Leader There Must Be Followers, But They Should Always Be On The Lookout For The Main Chance And Ready To Change Sides If The Current Leader Doesn't Deliver.

The History Of The Church Of Rome Is A Constant Leakage Of Members Into Such Breakaway Cults, Which Go On Splitting.

Religion Can Make It Worse. Are You Supposing That If People Were Encouraged To Believe In A Transcendent Reality, And To Be Encouraged By Grand Rituals And Music And Preaching, To Love Their Neighbors, Then They Would Put Jealousy And Frustration Aside?

Institutions Have The Pathetic Megalomania Of The Computer Whose Whole Vision Of The World Is Its Own Program.

Real Equality Is Immensely Difficult To Achieve, It Needs Continual Revision And Monitoring Of Distributions. And It Does Not Provide Buffers Between Members, So They Are Continually Colliding Or Frustrating Each Other.

Just In Our Lifetime Our Society Has Become Looser And More Private, It Becomes Extremely Difficult To Hold To Any Permanent Commitment Whatever, Least Of All To Organized Religion.

It Is Very Reasonable To Worry About The Harm Done By Organized Religion, And To Prefer Looser And More Private Arrangements.

It Seems True That The Growth Of Science And Secularism Made Organized Christianity Feel Under Threat.

It's Unlikely That The Organized Religions Will Get More Sectarian... Or Is It? I Am Not At All Sure.

Organized Religion

I Am Convinced That Living In An Enclave Shapes The Personality, And Living Alone Shapes The Personality Too.

Any Great Organization Can Go Through Sectarian Phases.

Great Organizations

It Is Only Partly True That Religion Does More Harm Than Good In Society. The Community Makes God Into The Image It Wants, Vengeful, Or Milky Sweet, Or Scrupulously Just, And So On.

The Natural Response Of The Old-timers Is To Build A Strong Moral Wall Against The Outside. This Is Where The World Starts To Be Painted In Black And White, Saints Inside, And Sinners Outside The Wall.

Black And White

When We Are Reflecting On Terrorism We Can Grieve For Many Things We Do And Have Done.

Hierarchy Is Is Much Reviled In The Present Day.

Where There Is Dirt There Is System. Dirt Is The Byproduct Of A Systematic Ordering And Classification Of Matter.

The Theory Of Cultural Bias... Is The Idea That A Culture Is Based On A Particular Form Of Organization. It Can't Be Transplanted Except To Another Variant Of That Organization.

Enclave Life Becomes Very Tense, Even When They Do Elect A Leader, The Factions Remain, With The Threat Of Splitting Off.

Without The Letters Of Condolence, Telegrams Of Congratulations And Even Occasional Postcards, The Friendship Of A Separated Friend Is Not A Social Reality. It Has No Existence Without The Rites Of Friendship. Social Rituals Create A Reality Which Would Be Nothing Without Them.

Congratulations

Some Scholars Have Been Arguing That A Civilizational Clash Between Organized Religions Is The Next Step In Human History.

The Human Body Is Always Treated As An Image Of Society.

I Am Sure It Must Be True That People Opt Out Of The Mainstream Society Because They Feel That There Are Going To Be No Rewards For Them, If They Stay.

Mainstream Society

If We Can Abstract Pathogenicity And Hygiene From Our Notion Of Dirt, We Are Left With The Old Definition Of Dirt As Matter Out Of Place. This Is A Very Suggestive Approach. It Implies Two Conditions: A Set Of Ordered Relations And A Contrevention Of That Order. Dirt Then, Is Never A Unique, Isolated Event. Where There Is Dirt There Is A System. Dirt Is The By-product Of A Systematic Ordering And Classification Of Matter, In So Far As Ordering Involves Rejecting Inappropriate Elements.

Hierarchy Works Well In A Stable Environment.

Pretensions To Moral Superiority Are Devastatingly Destructive.

If You Want To Change The Culture, You Will Have To Start By Changing The Organization.

Inside A Religious Body You Get Sects And Hierarchies, Inside An Information Network You Get Bazaars And Cathedrals, It Is The Same, Call Them What You Like. They Survive By Pointing The Finger Of Blame At Each Other.

Yes, Disappointment Over Perceived Unfairness, Injustice, Promises Not Kept, Tends To Go Hand In Hand With Increasing Prosperity. Expectations Are Dashed. What Can I Say!

Inequality Can Have A Bad Downside, But Equality, For Its Part, Sure Does Get In The Way Of Coordination.

If People Want To Compete For Leadership Of A Religious Group, They Can Compete In Piety. A Chilling Thought. Or Funny.

Every Year The Progress Of Advanced Capitalist Society Makes Our Population Consist Of More And More Isolates. This Is Because Of The Infrastructure Of The Economy, Especially Electronic Communications.

Our Technological Infrastructure Alienates Us From Each Other. No Need To Form A Workplace Community, Everybody There Will Be Out In A Year Or Two, And So Will You, Looking For A Better Place.

Islam Is In Principle Egalitarian, And Has Always Had Problems With Power.

Trending Author

Olivier Messiaen

Category