Background Image

...

Civil And Political Rights Are Critical, But Not Often The Real Problem For The Destitute Sick. My Patients In Haiti Can Now Vote But They Can't Get Medical Care Or Clean Water.

-Paul Farmer

...

Please Wait....
Translating....

Civil And Political Rights

Paul Farmer

...

Civil And Political Rights Are Critical, But Not Often The Real Problem For The Destitute Sick. My Patients In Haiti Can Now Vote But They Can't Get Medical Care Or Clean Water.

Views: 5

Topic

More From Paul Farmer

Equity Is The Only Acceptable Goal

Everybody Should Be Interested In Access To Primary And Secondary Education For Everybody.

But If You're Asking My Opinion, I Would Argue That A Social Justice Approach Should Be Central To Medicine And Utilized To Be Central To Public Health. This Could Be Very Simple: The Well Should Take Care Of The Sick.

For Me, An Area Of Moral Clarity Is: You're In Front Of Someone Who's Suffering And You Have The Tools At Your Disposal To Alleviate That Suffering Or Even Eradicate It, And You Act.

If Access To Health Care Is Considered A Human Right, Who Is Considered Human Enough To Have That Right?

I Would Say That, Intellectually, Catholicism Had No More Impact On Me Than Did Social Theory.

We Have To Design A Health Delivery System By Actually Talking To People And Asking, 'what Would Make This Service Better For You?' As Soon As You Start Asking, You Get A Flood Of Answers.

I Mean, Everybody Should Have Access To Medical Care. And, You Know, It Shouldn't Be Such A Big Deal.

There Is Nothing Wrong With Underlining Personal Agency, But There Is Something Unfair About Using Personal Responsibility As A Basis For Assigning Blame While Simultaneously Denying Those Who Are Being Blamed The Opportunity To Exert Agency In Their Lives

With Rare Exceptions, All Of Your Most Important Achievements On This Planet Will Come From Working With Others- Or, In A Word, Partnership.

Working With Others

If Any Country Was A Mine-shaft Canary For The Reintroduction Of Cholera, It Was Haiti - And We Knew It. And In Retrospect, More Should Have Been Done To Prepare For Cholera... Which Can Spread Like Wildfire In Haiti... This Was A Big Rebuke To All Of Us Working In Public Health And Health Care In Haiti.

Anywhere You Have Extreme Poverty And No National Health Insurance, No Promise Of Health Care Regardless Of Social Standing, That's Where You See The Sharp Limitations Of Market-based Health Care.

I Think That Looking Forward It's Easy To Imagine More Constructive Help For Haiti.

Again, Conventional Catholicism Does Not Much Appeal To Me.

The Human Rights Community Has Focused Very Narrowly On Political And Civil Rights For Many Decades, And With Reason, But Now We Have To Ask How Can We Broaden The View.

But As For Activism, My Parents Did What They Could, Given The Constraints, But Were Never Involved In The Causes I Think Of When I Think Of Activists.

The Thing About Rights Is That In The End You Can't Prove What Should Be Considered A Right.

Lean Water And Health Care And School And Food And Tin Roofs And Cement Floor, All Of These Things Should Constitute A Set Of Basics That People Must Have As Birthrights.

Some People Talk About Haiti As Being The Graveyard Of Development Projects.

I've Been Impressed, Over The Last 15 Years, With How Often The Somewhat Conspiratorial Comments Of Haitian Villagers Have Been Proven To Be Correct When The Historical Record Is Probed Carefully.

I Can't Sleep. There's Always Somebody Not Getting Treatment. I Can't Stand That.

I've Been Asked A Lot For My View On American Health Care. Well, 'it Would Be A Good Idea,' To Quote Gandhi.

Wl’s [white Liberals] Think All The World’s Problems Can Be Fixed Without Any Cost To Themselves. We Don’t Believe That. There’s A Lot To Be Said For Sacrifice, Remorse, Even Pity. It’s What Separates Us From Roaches

Since I Do Not Believe That There Should Be Different Recommendations For People Living In The Bronx And People Living In Manhattan, I Am Uncomfortable Making Different Recommendations For My Patients In Boston And In Haiti.

The World Is Full Of Miserable Places. One Way Of Living Comfortably Is Not To Think About Them Or, When You Do, To Send Money

The Biggest Public Health Challenge Is Rebuilding Health Systems. In Other Words, If You Look At Cholera Or Maternal Mortality Or Tuberculosis In Haiti, They're Major Problems In Haiti, But The Biggest Problem Is Rebuilding Systems.

God Gives Us Humans Everything We Need To Flourish, But He's Not The One Who's Supposed To Divvy Up The Loot. You Want To See Where Christ Crucified Abides Today? Go To Where The Poor Are Suffering And Fighting Back, And That's Where He Is.

Ebola Has Not Yet Come Into Contact With Modern Medicine In West Africa. But When Protocols For The Provision Of High Quality Supportive Care Are Followed, The Case Fatality Rate For Ebola May Be Lower Than 20 Percent.

At The Same Time, It Is Obvious That Clinicians In Haiti Are Faced With Different, And, In Fact, Greater, Challenges When Attempting To Treat Complications Of Hiv Disease.

The Essence Of Global Health Equity Is The Idea That Something So Precious As Health Might Be Viewed As A Right.

The Poorest Parts Of The World Are By And Large The Places In Which One Can Best View The Worst Of Medicine And Not Because Doctors In These Countries Have Different Ideas About What Constitutes Modern Medicine. It's The System And Its Limitations That Are To Blame.

Different Ideas

I Critique Market-based Medicine Not Because I Haven't Seen Its Heights But Because I've Seen Its Depths.

You Can't Have Public Health Without Working With The Public Sector. You Can't Have Public Education Without Working With The Public Sector In Education.

Public Education

I Recommend The Same Therapies For All Humans With Hiv. There Is No Reason To Believe That Physiologic Responses To Therapy Will Vary Across Lines Of Class, Culture, Race Or Nationality.

It Is Clear That The Pharmaceutical Industry Is Not, By Any Stretch Of The Imagination, Doing Enough To Ensure That The Poor Have Access To Adequate Medical Care.

I'm One Of Six Kids, And The Eight Of Us Lived For Over A Decade In Either A Bus Or A Boat.

The Model Of The Teaching Hospital, Which Links Research To Teaching And Service Is What's Missing In Global Health.

I Can't Think Of A Better Model For Haiti Rebuilding Than Rwanda.

Haiti Was Founderd By A Righteous Revolution In 1804 And Became The First Black Republic. It Was The First Country To Break The Chains Of Slavery, The First To Force Emperor Napoleon To Retreat, And The Only To Aid Simón Bolívar In His Struggle To Liberate The Indigenous People And Slaves Of Latin America From Their Colonial Oppressors.

You Can't Have Public Health Without A Public Health System. We Just Don't Want To Be Part Of A Mindless Competition For Resources. We Want To Build Back Capacity In The System.

I Think We Will See Better Vaccines Within The Next 15 Years, But I'm Not A Scientist And Am Focused On The Short-term - What Will Happen In The Interim.

Civil And Political Rights Are Critical, But Not Often The Real Problem For The Destitute Sick. My Patients In Haiti Can Now Vote But They Can't Get Medical Care Or Clean Water.

In An Age Of Explosive Development In The Realm Of Medical Technology, It Is Unnerving To Find That The Discoveries Of Salk, Sabin, And Even Pasteur Remain Irrelevant To Much Of Humanity.

People Call Me A Saint And I Think, I Have To Work Harder. Because A Saint Would Be A Great Thing To Be.

I Think, Sometimes, That I'm Going Nuts, And That Perhaps There Is Something Good About Blocking Clean Water For Those Who Have None, Making Sure That Illiterate Children Remain So, And Preventing The Resuscitation Of The Public Health Sector In The Country Most In Need Of It. Lunacy Is What It Is.

The Idea That Some Lives Matter Less Is The Root Of All That Is Wrong With The World.

We Want To Be On The Winning Team, But At The Risk Of Turning Our Backs On The Losers, No, It Is Not Worth It. So We Fight The Long Defeat.

The Only Way To Do The Human Rights Thing Is To Do The Right Thing Medically.

If You Look Just At The Decades After 1934, You Know It's Hard To Point To Really Inspired And Positive Support From Outside Of Haiti, To Haiti, And Much Easier To Point To Either Small-minded Or Downright Mean-spirited Policies.

...in A World Riven By Inequity, Medicine Could Be Viewed As Social Justice Work.

I Feel It's Part Of My Job To Make The Problems Of The Poor Compelling.

60% Of Workers Surveyed Said If Their Employer Took Action To Support The Mental Wellbeing Of All Staff, They Would Feel More Loyal, Motivated, Committed And Be Likely To Recommend Their Workplace As A Good Place To Work.

It Is Very Expensive To Give Bad Medical Care To Poor People In A Rich Country.

If I Am Hungry, That Is A Material Problem; If Someone Else Is Hungry, That Is A Spiritual Problem.

I'm Not An Austere Person.

In Fact, It Seems To Me That Making Strategic Alliances Across National Borders In Order To Treat Hiv Among The World's Poor Is One Of The Last Great Hopes Of Solidarity Across A Widening Divide.

That's When I Feel Most Alive, When I'm Helping People.

The Idea That Because You're Born In Haiti You Could Die Having A Child. The Idea That Because You're Born In You Know Malawi Your Children May Go To Bed Hungry. We Want To Take Some Of The Chance Out Of That.

Haiti Is Always Talking About Decentralization And Nothing Has Been So Obvious, Perhaps A Weakness, As The Centralized Nature Of Haitian Society As Being Revealed By The Earthquake. I Mean, They Lost All These Medical Training Programs Because They Didn't Have Them Anywhere Else.

What I Can Argue Is That No One Should Have To Die Of A Disease That Is Treatable.

We've Taken On The Major Health Problems Of The Poorest - Tuberculosis, Maternal Mortality, Aids, Malaria - In Four Countries. We've Scored Some Victories In The Sense That We've Cured Or Treated Thousands And Changed The Discourse About What Is Possible.

Trending Author

Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

Category